Black Turtlenecks

This article was last updated on April 16, 2022

Canada: Free $30 Oye! Times readers Get FREE $30 to spend on Amazon, Walmart…
USA: Free $30 Oye! Times readers Get FREE $30 to spend on Amazon, Walmart…

Welcome to Hype Machine, our hit-list of the top reviewed products across the web — according to a crowd of die-hard shoppers. Call this your 4-star & up only club, with entry granted by our devoted-to-the-goods shop editors

When you think of the black turtleneck's place in the fashion world, there are a handful of iconic moments that come to mind. Audrey Hepburn's debut as a bohémienne in Funny Face, Karl Lagerfeld taking a final bow after one of his (many) runway shows, Steve Jobs being well, Steve Jobs. The cold weather staple has managed to transcend all genders, regardless of personal style, since the 1920s. And as our modern wardrobes can attest, it's still kicking.

With so many options to choose from — oversized, slim-fitting, cropped, cable-knit, cashmere — how do you go about sussing out the best ones worth buying? As with most things on the internet, it turns out the review sections for black turtlenecks are rife with opinions. So to save you the headache of having to deal with shipping returns, we've thrown together a list of all of the internet's pre-approved options. Whether you're searching for a reliable heattech top to get you through winter, or just hoping to recreate a Dwayne The Rock Johnson costume next Halloween, shop these ten top-rated picks ahead.

[AdSense-C]​

Black Turtlenecks,

Everlane The Cashmere Square Turtleneck

Come winter, we're all in the business of avoiding "bulk" wherever we can. A cropped cut is an easy solution for evading unnecessary bunching under our thick coats. You can easily toss this cashmere sweater over any pair of pants, no tucking or styling tricks needed.

The hype: 4.77 out of 5 stars and 880 reviews on Everlane

What they're saying: "This sweater is the perfect amount of boxy. It’s fitted in the chest and then gives a nice flow of fabric around your stomach. It’s also the perfect length- not too long, not too cropped. The stitching details on the sleeve are so pretty, and the length of the turtleneck lands more in the middle of your neck which looks so much more effortless. Such an amazing style for wanting that classic look without having to wear something fitted. Love!" – Bar61, Everlane review

Everlane The Cashmere Square Turtleneck, $, available at Everlane

Black Turtlenecks,

Uniqlo Heattech Turtleneck Long-Sleeve T-Shirt

Uniqlo's Heattech turtleneck should be a staple in any Winter Survival Kit. Apart from being comfortable, its next-level insulation ensures you'll never feel freezing again.

The hype: 4.9 out of 5 stars and 224 reviews on Uniqlo

What they're saying: "I love it! The fabric is very light, soft, and elastic which makes it really comfortable, yet it's not see-through. The best part is that the Heattech fabric actually works and it keeps you warmer than you'd expect from a similar article of clothing. The style is fitted but it stretches nicely…This is a great top to take on a trip, since it doesn't occupy much space and it's versatile enough to be worn as a base layer or on its own. – Mariajose, Uniqlo review

Uniqlo Heattech Turtleneck Long-Sleeve T-Shirt, $, available at Uniqlo

Black Turtlenecks,

Gap Cable-Knit Turtleneck Tunic Sweater

If you're looking for a cozy sweater to cuddle up in, try this slightly oversized cable-knit. The relaxed fit and thick material make this turtleneck the perfect piece of loungewear.

The hype: 4.7 out of 5 stars and 110 reviews on Gap

What they're saying: "I feel like the lead in a Hallmark holiday movie in this sweater. It's very warm. Sleeves and torso are a good length. Quintessential knit sweater!" – Cyocks, Gap review

Gap Cable-Knit Turtleneck Tunic Sweater, $, available at Gap

Black Turtlenecks,

Athleta Foresthill Merino Wool Ascent Turtleneck

Thumbholes. Enough said. But in all seriousness, this stretchy wool-blend top is a great accessory for outdoor adventures. The thumbholes are merely a plus.

The hype: 4.9 out of 5 stars and 103 reviews on Athleta

What they're saying: "I've been looking for a basic black turtleneck that can be dressed up or down and that packs down to almost nothing – and I've found it! The material is buttery soft, surprisingly warm, and it's easy to take on and off (which I don't typically find to be the case with turtlenecks)." – Cricket, Athleta review

Athleta Foresthill Merino Wool Ascent Turtleneck, $, available at Athleta

Black Turtlenecks,

 

C by Bloomingdale's Cashmere Turtleneck Sweater

Face the cold head-on in a buttery soft cashmere top. Bloomingdale’s makes a rib-knit trim turtleneck that reviewers can’t stop buying in multiple colorways. 

The hype: 4.4 out of 5 stars and 70 reviews on Bloomingdale's

What they're saying: "I was on the search for cashmere turtlenecks when I came across this one. I read the reviews, so I sized up to a large (5'4", 34 DD, 140 lbs) and it fits exactly the way I want – fitted but not tight. I also chose this turtleneck based on the reviews regarding the neck; I like a turtleneck to be snug. I didn't find it tight, but it's not loose or sloppy; it stays upright which is what I wanted. The sweater itself has a nice, soft feel. It's isn't thin or bulky. I am thrilled with my purchase; besides the black, I also bought the navy and the dark charcoal." – Caroline8, Bloomingdale’s review

C by Bloomingdale's Cashmere Turtleneck Sweater, $, available at Bloomingdale's

Black Turtlenecks,

L.L.Bean Pima Cotton Turtleneck

And the crowd goes wild for this longtime fan favorite. With over 1100 positive reviews, this Supima cotton top has proven itself to be a tried and true pick over the last couple of decades.

The hype: 4.4 out of 5 stars and 1135 reviews on L.L.Bean

What they're saying: "I've been buying these pima cotton turtlenecks for over 20 years and you'd think there'd be nothing new to say, but these are the features that make this one the best yet. The neck is sized just right, not too tight or loose. The length of the neck fabric is just right, long enough to wear scrunched or traditionally folded over with an ample fold. The arms are long enough to cover my long arms over the wrist and full enough to not be tight to the arm." – Sagebrushgal, L.L.Bean review

L.L. Bean Pima Cotton Turtleneck, $, available at L.L. Bean

Black Turtlenecks,

A New Day Turtleneck Ribbed Sweatshirt

You likely speed-clicked through this article on the hunt for the most affordable option. Well congrats, you've found it. But while the price of this top might be cheap, the amount of five-star reviews proves the quality is far from it.

The hype: 4.7 out of 5 stars and 113 reviews on Target

What they're saying: "WOW! I loveeeee this turtleneck sooo much! Pros: #1 You don't feel like you're being strangled with this turtleneck #2 The material is so soft! I chose not to dry when I did wash them #3 I love that the length is great #4 The price is amazing! #5 I love that this is a perfect top to layer or wear on it's own due to it not being extremely thick…" – Creativechristy, Target review

A New Day Turtleneck Ribbed Sweatshirt, $, available at Target

Black Turtlenecks,

J.Crew Tissue Turtleneck

Meet the quintessential classic black turtleneck. Made from cotton, it's lightweight enough to layer yet warm enough to wear on its own, super-soft, and holds a shape that's not too tight, not too relaxed, but just right.

The hype: 4.3 out of 5 stars and 204 reviews on J.Crew

What they're saying: "I have a sensitive neck and can't stand something rubbing at it all day. Yet, many fall and winter styles require this stand-alone or layering piece. What to do? Well, for me, it is the tissue turtleneck. Very soft, very fine material and not at all tight. I was worried the fabric would be see-through and not substantial enough to wear a wool sweater over without being itchy. But it is substantial enough. I highly recommend to those with my sensitive skin issues…" – Judyinslc, J.Crew review

J.Crew Tissue Turtleneck, $, available at J.Crew

Black Turtlenecks,

Wosalba Long Sleeve Turtleneck Slim Top

This slim and snug top is the perfect base layer. The body-hugging fit allows you to prolong your warmer weather wardrobe when layered under your favorite dress or tee. And according to reviews, your purchase also comes with a surprise necklace completely gratis (we don't pretend to completely understand the ways of Amazon storefronts), so you get even more bang for your buck.

The hype: 4.5 out of 5 stars and 1,202 reviews on Amazon

What they're saying: "…I am a big busted woman and I hate it when a shirt makes me look even larger. I tend to wear v-neck clothing or peephole shirts to avoid that giant boob look. However, this shirt does not give that giant boob effect! It is nice and stretchy and comfortable. I especially love the length. I am not pulling it down all day. It stays put and can be worn at work with slacks (as I have on now) or on the weekends with some cute leggings. I have gotten so many compliments. I love the faux turtle neck, the material is not see through either, but it is nice and light weight…I will be ordering some more!!! – Niecy, Amazon review

Wosalba Long Sleeve Turtleneck Slim Top, $, available at Amazon

Black Turtlenecks,

Aerie Chenille Oversized Turtleneck

Planning on living in leggings and an oversized turtleneck sweater for the next couple of months? Then you've come to the right place. This chenille pullover from Aerie literally boasts "Made For Leggings!" in its description.

The hype: 4.4 out of 5 stars and 189 reviews on American Eagle Outfitters

What they're saying: "I love this sweater! It feels like I'm wearing a blanket but can still be dressed up (or down, depending on the day). I personally really value comfort in the clothes I buy so this was perfect for me. I wear it at least once a week and I always get compliments on it!.." – Emma, American Eagle Outfitter's review

Aerie Chenille Oversized Turtleneck, $, available at American Eagle Outfitters

Click HERE to read more.


You can publish this article on your website as long as you provide a link back to this page.

Share with friends
You can publish this article on your website as long as you provide a link back to this page.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*